What Are Personal Minimums?

“What are your personal minimums? Do you even know? Have you established them? Have you safely established them? Have you even thought about them?”

It’s a simple question, but it gets to one of the most important parts of becoming a safe and proficient pilot. Our Founder and Platinum CSIP Jonathan says, “At CalAir, we spend a lot of time teaching what the aircraft can do, but pilots also need to understand what they are comfortable and proficient doing. Developing good personal minimums is part of flying 101.”

Personal minimums are essentially weather or performance conditions that may not be dangerous for the aircraft or the flight, but that you may not personally be comfortable exceeding. That distinction is important because aircraft capability and pilot capability are not always the same thing.

One pilot may be comfortable flying in continual light turbulence while another is not. One pilot may comfortably fly an instrument approach to published minimums while another wants the ceiling at least 500 feet higher. The airplane may have more than enough performance to operate from a short runway, but that does not automatically mean the pilot is ready or comfortable doing it.

The important part is knowing where your limits are before you find yourself testing them alone.

If you’re curious, the FAA also has a downloadable PDF you can reference: Personal Minimums Checklist.

What Are Personal Minimums?

Personal minimums are standards you establish for yourself based on your training, experience, proficiency, and comfort level. They provide another layer of decision-making beyond asking whether a flight is technically possible or legal.

A simple example is turbulence. If the forecast is calling for light turbulence, you may be completely comfortable making the flight. If moderate or stronger turbulence is expected, you may decide that is outside your personal minimums. Another pilot with significantly more experience may make a different decision.

As Jonathan puts it, “You’ve got to know what you’re cool with.”

That sounds simple, but there is a lot behind it. You need enough experience to know how you respond to different conditions, how the airplane performs, and at what point your workload or comfort level begins affecting your ability to fly well.

Aircraft Limits and Personal Limits Are Two Different Things

One of the easiest mistakes to make is treating an aircraft limitation, regulation, or published procedure as your own personal standard.

They are not necessarily the same.

An aircraft may be approved to operate within a particular set of conditions, and a procedure may legally allow you to continue, but that does not mean every pilot should be operating at the outer edge of those limits.

IFR flying is a good example. Some pilots are comfortable flying an approach all the way down to published minimums. Another pilot may decide they will not shoot an approach unless the ceiling is at least 500 feet above minimums.

The second pilot is not saying the published approach is unsafe. They are simply establishing additional margin based on their own experience and proficiency. This is what personal minimums are about.

Crosswinds: How Much Can You Handle?

Crosswinds were one of the first examples that came up in our discussion because they make the concept easy to understand.

How much crosswind are you comfortable landing in?

Your answer may be different from another Cirrus pilot’s answer, and your own answer may change as you gain experience. A newer pilot who has primarily trained in light winds should probably not use the same personal minimum as someone who regularly operates in stronger crosswinds.

This is also where training can help establish a meaningful limit rather than an arbitrary number. If you want to become more comfortable with stronger crosswinds, ask your CalAir instructor to work on them with you when the right conditions arrive. You can experience how the airplane responds, work on your technique, and determine where your current comfort level actually is.

As your proficiency improves, your personal minimum may change with it.

Turbulence: Safe for the Aircraft vs. Comfortable for You

Turbulence brings up the same distinction.

A bumpy ride is not automatically a dangerous ride. There may be conditions that remain acceptable for the aircraft but that you personally do not enjoy or do not yet feel proficient operating in.

Some pilots may be comfortable with light or continual light chop. Others may be willing to operate in considerably rougher conditions when the aircraft and flight allow it.

The personal side of that decision matters. Are you able to keep a clear head? Are you still comfortably managing the airplane and workload? Are the conditions distracting you enough that you start making mistakes?

If you have never experienced meaningful turbulence before, it is difficult to answer those questions from a weather report alone. That is one reason we sometimes use appropriate windy or turbulent conditions as a training opportunity.

You get to experience the conditions with a CalAir instructor onboard, learn how the airplane responds, and begin figuring out what you would or would not be comfortable handling by yourself.

IFR Minimums: How Low Are You Comfortable Going?

Instrument flying is another area where personal minimums become very important.

As mentioned earlier, one pilot may be perfectly comfortable flying an approach to published minimums. Another pilot may want a ceiling at least 500 feet above minimums before attempting the same approach.

Neither decision changes the published approach. What changes is the individual pilot’s level of experience, proficiency, and comfort.

Actual low ceilings and reduced visibility can also feel very different from looking at those numbers during flight planning. If you want to become more comfortable in real IFR conditions, take advantage of appropriate weather when it comes to Southern California and fly it with your instructor.

The goal is not to immediately get comfortable operating at the lowest possible minimum. The goal is to build enough real experience that your personal minimum is based on something meaningful.

Short Runways: How Short Are You Comfortable With?

Runway length was another major example from our conversation.

Hawthorne Airport has roughly 4,884 feet of runway, which gives Cirrus Aircraft plenty of room for normal operations. Compare that with an airport such as Oceano County near Pismo Beach, where the runway is roughly 2,300 feet, or other airports like Fallbrook which have runways closer to 2,000 feet.

A Cirrus may be capable of safely operating from a shorter runway under the right conditions (recall our What Hot Weather Does to Aircraft Performance blog).

But the personal-minimum question is different:

“How short of a runway are you comfortable flying into?”

As the available runway gets shorter, the margin becomes more noticeable. At some point during a short-runway departure, you can also become committed to continuing the takeoff and handling a problem in the air rather than simply stopping on the remaining runway.

That changes how the operation feels and how you plan for it. It is one thing to calculate the numbers and know the airplane can do it. It is another thing to experience the environment firsthand.

This Is Where Destination-Based Training Becomes Valuable

Personal minimums are one of the reasons we believe destination-based flight training is so useful.

Instead of always operating from the same familiar airport, we can use a lesson to expose you to a different runway, airport environment, terrain, weather pattern, or operating condition. A shorter runway that looks perfectly manageable on paper may feel very different when you see it approaching through the windshield.

Jonathan summarized the value of this type of training as:

“Go see what you’re going to be okay with an instructor and what you’re not going to be okay with.”

That is really the point.

If you want to know whether a shorter runway belongs inside your personal minimums, go train at one. If you want to better understand stronger crosswinds, practice them with your instructor. If turbulence makes you uncomfortable, experience appropriate conditions with someone beside you who can help you understand what the aircraft is doing.

You shouldn’t discover the edge of your personal minimums for the first time while you’re alone.

Have You Safely Established Your Personal Minimums?

This is the part of Jonathan’s original question that we think pilots should spend more time thinking about.

It is easy to write down a number.

It is more valuable to understand why that number is your limit.

Have you safely experienced the conditions you’re setting a minimum around? Is your limit based on actual training and experience, or are you guessing? Are you still as proficient as you were when you established it?

Some of the big areas worth discussing with your instructor include:

  • Crosswind component
  • Turbulence
  • IFR ceilings and visibility
  • Instrument approach minimums
  • Runway length
  • Weather conditions
  • Density altitude and aircraft performance
  • Terrain and unfamiliar airport environments

The FAA also provides a Personal Minimums Checklist that can help pilots think through these areas. It is a useful starting point, but we would encourage you to take it one step further and review it with your instructor.

Your Personal Minimums Should Develop as You Do

Personal minimums are not necessarily permanent.

As you gain meaningful experience, stay proficient, and receive additional training, your limits may evolve. A crosswind that once felt challenging may become routine. Actual IFR experience may make you more comfortable operating with lower ceilings. Repeated short-field and destination training may expand the types of airports you are comfortable using.

But the order matters.

Build the skill first. Then reconsider the minimum.

Don’t lower a personal minimum simply because you really want today’s flight to happen.

If you want to expand a limit, use training to do it intentionally.

Talk to Your CalAir Instructor

If you have never really thought through your personal minimums, now is a good time to start.

Ask yourself:

What are your personal minimums? Have you established them? More importantly, have you safely established them?

Then bring those questions to your CalAir instructor.

As a Cirrus Certified Platinum Training Center, we can help you identify areas where additional experience would be useful and incorporate them into your training when conditions are appropriate. That may mean crosswind practice, actual IFR experience, turbulence, shorter runways, or using destination-based lessons to put you into a different operating environment.

Personal minimums are not about creating a list of conditions you’re afraid to fly in. They are about understanding what you are capable of today and using good training to safely become a more capable pilot tomorrow.

As always, our blog posts are intended to educate and challenge you to learn more and become a better pilot. Not every insight or consideration is discussed here. Talk to your CalAir instructor to learn more.

Frequently Asked Questions About Personal Minimums

What are personal minimums in aviation?

Personal minimums are limits a pilot establishes based on their own training, experience, proficiency, and comfort level. They can apply to weather and aircraft performance conditions such as crosswinds, turbulence, IFR ceilings and visibility, runway length, density altitude, and other operating conditions.

Are personal minimums the same as aircraft or FAA limits?

No. An aircraft or published procedure may allow an operation that a pilot personally decides is beyond their current comfort or proficiency level. Personal minimums can provide additional margin beyond the applicable aircraft, regulatory, or procedural limits.

Can personal minimums be more conservative than published IFR minimums?

Yes. For example, a pilot may decide not to attempt an instrument approach unless the ceiling is 500 feet above the published minimum, even though the approach itself allows operation lower than that.

How do I establish my personal minimums?

Start with the conditions you have already experienced and honestly evaluate what you are comfortable and proficient handling. Then discuss those limits with your flight instructor and use training to gain experience in areas where you want to become more capable.

Should personal minimums change as I gain experience?

They can. As training, experience, and proficiency increase, some personal minimums may change. The important point is to build the skill first and adjust the minimum afterward rather than lowering a limit simply to make a particular flight happen.

Can CalAir help me establish my personal minimums?

Yes. Talk with your CalAir instructor about the areas you want to better understand. When conditions are appropriate, training can include crosswinds, turbulence, actual IFR conditions, shorter runways, and destination-based flying to help you establish your limits through supervised experience.

CONTACT US TO LEARN MORE
CalAir Aviation — Home call us